perlfaq7 - General Perl Language Issues

- NAME
- DESCRIPTION

- Can I get a BNF/yacc/RE for the Perl language?
- What are all these $@%&* punctuation signs, and how do I know when to use them?
- Do I always/never have to quote my strings or use semicolons and commas?
- How do I skip some return values?
- How do I temporarily block warnings?
- What's an extension?
- Why do Perl operators have different precedence than C operators?
- How do I declare/create a structure?
- How do I create a module?
- How do I create a class?
- How can I tell if a variable is tainted?
- What's a closure?
- What is variable suicide and how can I prevent it?
- How can I pass/return a {Function, FileHandle, Array, Hash, Method, Regex}?
- How do I create a static variable?
- What's the difference between dynamic and lexical (static) scoping? Between `local()` and my()?
- How can I access a dynamic variable while a similarly named lexical is in scope?
- What's the difference between deep and shallow binding?
- Why doesn't ``my($foo) = <FILE>;'' work right?
- How do I redefine a builtin function, operator, or method?
- What's the difference between calling a function as &foo and foo()?
- How do I create a switch or case statement?
- How can I catch accesses to undefined variables, functions, or methods?
- Why can't a method included in this same file be found?
- How can I find out my current package?
- How can I comment out a large block of perl code?
- How do I clear a package?
- How can I use a variable as a variable name?
- What does ``bad interpreter'' mean?

- AUTHOR AND COPYRIGHT

# NAME

perlfaq7 - General Perl Language Issues ($Revision: 1.18 $, $Date: 2004/11/03 22:54:08 $)

# DESCRIPTION

This section deals with general Perl language issues that don't clearly fit into any of the other sections.

## Can I get a BNF/yacc/RE for the Perl language?

There is no BNF, but you can paw your way through the yacc grammar in perly.y in the source distribution if you're particularly brave. The grammar relies on very smart tokenizing code, so be prepared to venture into toke.c as well.

In the words of Chaim Frenkel: ``Perl's grammar can not be reduced to BNF. The work of parsing perl is distributed between yacc, the lexer, smoke and mirrors.''

## What are all these $@%&* punctuation signs, and how do I know when to use them?

They are type specifiers, as detailed in the perldata manpage:

        $ for scalar values (number, string or reference)
        @ for arrays
        % for hashes (associative arrays)
        & for subroutines (aka functions, procedures, methods)
        * for all types of that symbol name.  In version 4 you used them like
          pointers, but in modern perls you can just use references.

There are couple of other symbols that you're likely to encounter that aren't really type specifiers:

        <> are used for inputting a record from a filehandle.
        \  takes a reference to something.

Note that <FILE> is neither the type specifier for files nor the name of the handle. It is the `<>` operator applied to the handle FILE. It reads one line (well, record--see $/ in the perlvar manpage) from the handle FILE in scalar context, or all lines in list context. When performing open, close, or any other operation besides `<>` on files, or even when talking about the handle, do not use the brackets. These are correct: `eof(FH)`, `seek(FH, 0, 2)` and ``copying from STDIN to FILE''.

## Do I always/never have to quote my strings or use semicolons and commas?

Normally, a bareword doesn't need to be quoted, but in most cases probably should be (and must be under `use strict`). But a hash key consisting of a simple word (that isn't the name of a defined subroutine) and the left-hand operand to the `=>` operator both count as though they were quoted:

        This                    is like this
        ------------            ---------------
        $foo{line}              $foo{"line"}
        bar => stuff            "bar" => stuff

The final semicolon in a block is optional, as is the final comma in a list. Good style (see the perlstyle manpage) says to put them in except for one-liners:

        if ($whoops) { exit 1 }
        @nums = (1, 2, 3);

        if ($whoops) {
            exit 1;
        }
        @lines = (
            "There Beren came from mountains cold",
            "And lost he wandered under leaves",
        );

## How do I skip some return values?

One way is to treat the return values as a list and index into it:

            $dir = (getpwnam($user))[7];

Another way is to use undef as an element on the left-hand-side:

        ($dev, $ino, undef, undef, $uid, $gid) = stat($file);

You can also use a list slice to select only the elements that you need:

            ($dev, $ino, $uid, $gid) = ( stat($file) )[0,1,4,5];

## How do I temporarily block warnings?

If you are running Perl 5.6.0 or better, the `use warnings` pragma allows fine control of what warning are produced. See the perllexwarn manpage for more details.

        {
            no warnings;          # temporarily turn off warnings
            $a = $b + $c;         # I know these might be undef
        }

    Additionally, you can enable and disable categories of warnings.
    You turn off the categories you want to ignore and you can still
    get other categories of warnings.  See L<perllexwarn> for the
    complete details, including the category names and hierarchy.

            {
            no warnings 'uninitialized';
            $a = $b + $c;
            }

If you have an older version of Perl, the `$^W` variable (documented in the perlvar manpage) controls runtime warnings for a block:

        {
            local $^W = 0;        # temporarily turn off warnings
            $a = $b + $c;         # I know these might be undef
        }

Note that like all the punctuation variables, you cannot currently use `my()` on `$^W`, only local().

## What's an extension?

An extension is a way of calling compiled C code from Perl. Reading the perlxstut manpage is a good place to learn more about extensions.

## Why do Perl operators have different precedence than C operators?

Actually, they don't. All C operators that Perl copies have the same precedence in Perl as they do in C. The problem is with operators that C doesn't have, especially functions that give a list context to everything on their right, eg. print, chmod, exec, and so on. Such functions are called ``list operators'' and appear as such in the precedence table in the perlop manpage.

A common mistake is to write:

        unlink $file || die "snafu";

This gets interpreted as:

        unlink ($file || die "snafu");

To avoid this problem, either put in extra parentheses or use the super low precedence `or` operator:

        (unlink $file) || die "snafu";
        unlink $file or die "snafu";

The ``English'' operators (`and`, `or`, `xor`, and `not`) deliberately have precedence lower than that of list operators for just such situations as the one above.

Another operator with surprising precedence is exponentiation. It binds more tightly even than unary minus, making `-2**2` product a negative not a positive four. It is also right-associating, meaning that `2**3**2` is two raised to the ninth power, not eight squared.

Although it has the same precedence as in C, Perl's `?:` operator produces an lvalue. This assigns $x to either $a or $b, depending on the trueness of $maybe:

        ($maybe ? $a : $b) = $x;

## How do I declare/create a structure?

In general, you don't ``declare'' a structure. Just use a (probably anonymous) hash reference. See the perlref manpage and the perldsc manpage for details. Here's an example:

        $person = {};                   # new anonymous hash
        $person->{AGE}  = 24;           # set field AGE to 24
        $person->{NAME} = "Nat";        # set field NAME to "Nat"

If you're looking for something a bit more rigorous, try the perltoot manpage.

## How do I create a module?

A module is a package that lives in a file of the same name. For example, the Hello::There module would live in Hello/There.pm. For details, read the perlmod manpage. You'll also find the Exporter manpage helpful. If you're writing a C or mixed-language module with both C and Perl, then you should study the perlxstut manpage.

The `h2xs` program will create stubs for all the important stuff for you:

      % h2xs -XA -n My::Module

The `-X` switch tells `h2xs` that you are not using `XS` extension code. The `-A` switch tells `h2xs` that you are not using the AutoLoader, and the `-n` switch specifies the name of the module. See h2xs for more details.

## How do I create a class?

See the perltoot manpage for an introduction to classes and objects, as well as the perlobj manpage and the perlbot manpage.

## How can I tell if a variable is tainted?

You can use the `tainted()` function of the Scalar::Util module, available from CPAN (or included with Perl since release 5.8.0). See also Laundering and Detecting Tainted Data in the perlsec manpage.

## What's a closure?

Closures are documented in the perlref manpage.

Closure is a computer science term with a precise but hard-to-explain meaning. Closures are implemented in Perl as anonymous subroutines with lasting references to lexical variables outside their own scopes. These lexicals magically refer to the variables that were around when the subroutine was defined (deep binding).

Closures make sense in any programming language where you can have the return value of a function be itself a function, as you can in Perl. Note that some languages provide anonymous functions but are not capable of providing proper closures: the Python language, for example. For more information on closures, check out any textbook on functional programming. Scheme is a language that not only supports but encourages closures.

Here's a classic function-generating function:

        sub add_function_generator {
          return sub { shift() + shift() };
        }

        $add_sub = add_function_generator();
        $sum = $add_sub->(4,5);                # $sum is 9 now.

The closure works as a function template with some customization slots left out to be filled later. The anonymous subroutine returned by `add_function_generator()` isn't technically a closure because it refers to no lexicals outside its own scope.

Contrast this with the following `make_adder()` function, in which the returned anonymous function contains a reference to a lexical variable outside the scope of that function itself. Such a reference requires that Perl return a proper closure, thus locking in for all time the value that the lexical had when the function was created.

        sub make_adder {
            my $addpiece = shift;
            return sub { shift() + $addpiece };
        }

        $f1 = make_adder(20);
        $f2 = make_adder(555);

Now `&$f1($n)` is always 20 plus whatever $n you pass in, whereas `&$f2($n)` is always 555 plus whatever $n you pass in. The $addpiece in the closure sticks around.

Closures are often used for less esoteric purposes. For example, when you want to pass in a bit of code into a function:

        my $line;
        timeout( 30, sub { $line = <STDIN> } );

If the code to execute had been passed in as a string, `'$line = <STDIN>'`, there would have been no way for the hypothetical `timeout()` function to access the lexical variable $line back in its caller's scope.

## What is variable suicide and how can I prevent it?

Variable suicide is when you (temporarily or permanently) lose the value of a variable. It is caused by scoping through `my()` and `local()` interacting with either closures or aliased `foreach()` iterator variables and subroutine arguments. It used to be easy to inadvertently lose a variable's value this way, but now it's much harder. Take this code:

        my $f = "foo";
        sub T {
          while ($i++ < 3) { my $f = $f; $f .= "bar"; print $f, "\n" }
        }
        T;
        print "Finally $f\n";

The $f that has ``bar'' added to it three times should be a new `$f` (`my $f` should create a new local variable each time through the loop). It isn't, however. This was a bug, now fixed in the latest releases (tested against 5.004_05, 5.005_03, and 5.005_56).

## How can I pass/return a {Function, FileHandle, Array, Hash, Method, Regex}?

With the exception of regexes, you need to pass references to these objects. See Pass by Reference in the perlsub manpage for this particular question, and the perlref manpage for information on references.

See ``Passing Regexes'', below, for information on passing regular expressions.

Passing Variables and Functions
  Regular variables and functions are quite easy to pass: just pass in a reference to an existing or anonymous variable or function:

          func( \$some_scalar );

          func( \@some_array  );
          func( [ 1 .. 10 ]   );

          func( \%some_hash   );
          func( { this => 10, that => 20 }   );

          func( \&some_func   );
          func( sub { $_[0] ** $_[1] }   );

Passing Filehandles
  As of Perl 5.6, you can represent filehandles with scalar variables which you treat as any other scalar.

              open my $fh, $filename or die "Cannot open $filename! $!";
              func( $fh );

              sub func {
                      my $passed_fh = shift;

                      my $line = <$fh>;
                      }

  Before Perl 5.6, you had to use the `*FH` or `\*FH` notations. These are ``typeglobs''--see Typeglobs and Filehandles in the perldata manpage and especially Pass by Reference in the perlsub manpage for more information.

Passing Regexes
  To pass regexes around, you'll need to be using a release of Perl sufficiently recent as to support the `qr//` construct, pass around strings and use an exception-trapping eval, or else be very, very clever.

  Here's an example of how to pass in a string to be regex compared using `qr//`:

          sub compare($$) {
              my ($val1, $regex) = @_;
              my $retval = $val1 =~ /$regex/;
              return $retval;
          }
          $match = compare("old McDonald", qr/d.*D/i);

  Notice how `qr//` allows flags at the end. That pattern was compiled at compile time, although it was executed later. The nifty `qr//` notation wasn't introduced until the 5.005 release. Before that, you had to approach this problem much less intuitively. For example, here it is again if you don't have `qr//`:

          sub compare($$) {
              my ($val1, $regex) = @_;
              my $retval = eval { $val1 =~ /$regex/ };
              die if $@;
              return $retval;
          }

          $match = compare("old McDonald", q/($?i)d.*D/);

  Make sure you never say something like this:

          return eval "\$val =~ /$regex/";   # WRONG

  or someone can sneak shell escapes into the regex due to the double interpolation of the eval and the double-quoted string. For example:

          $pattern_of_evil = 'danger ${ system("rm -rf * &") } danger';

          eval "\$string =~ /$pattern_of_evil/";

  Those preferring to be very, very clever might see the O'Reilly book, Mastering Regular Expressions, by Jeffrey Friedl. Page 273's `Build_MatchMany_Function()` is particularly interesting. A complete citation of this book is given in the perlfaq2 manpage.

Passing Methods
  To pass an object method into a subroutine, you can do this:

          call_a_lot(10, $some_obj, "methname")
          sub call_a_lot {
              my ($count, $widget, $trick) = @_;
              for (my $i = 0; $i < $count; $i++) {
                  $widget->$trick();
              }
          }

  Or, you can use a closure to bundle up the object, its method call, and arguments:

          my $whatnot =  sub { $some_obj->obfuscate(@args) };
          func($whatnot);
          sub func {
              my $code = shift;
              &$code();
          }

  You could also investigate the `can()` method in the UNIVERSAL class (part of the standard perl distribution).

## How do I create a static variable?

As with most things in Perl, TMTOWTDI. What is a ``static variable'' in other languages could be either a function-private variable (visible only within a single function, retaining its value between calls to that function), or a file-private variable (visible only to functions within the file it was declared in) in Perl.

Here's code to implement a function-private variable:

        BEGIN {
            my $counter = 42;
            sub prev_counter { return --$counter }
            sub next_counter { return $counter++ }
        }

Now `prev_counter()` and `next_counter()` share a private variable $counter that was initialized at compile time.

To declare a file-private variable, you'll still use a my(), putting the declaration at the outer scope level at the top of the file. Assume this is in file Pax.pm:

        package Pax;
        my $started = scalar(localtime(time()));

        sub begun { return $started }

When `use Pax` or `require Pax` loads this module, the variable will be initialized. It won't get garbage-collected the way most variables going out of scope do, because the `begun()` function cares about it, but no one else can get it. It is not called $Pax::started because its scope is unrelated to the package. It's scoped to the file. You could conceivably have several packages in that same file all accessing the same private variable, but another file with the same package couldn't get to it.

See Persistent Private Variables in the perlsub manpage for details.

## What's the difference between dynamic and lexical (static) scoping? Between `local()` and my()?

`local($x)` saves away the old value of the global variable `$x` and assigns a new value for the duration of the subroutine which is visible in other functions called from that subroutine. This is done at run-time, so is called dynamic scoping. `local()` always affects global variables, also called package variables or dynamic variables.

`my($x)` creates a new variable that is only visible in the current subroutine. This is done at compile-time, so it is called lexical or static scoping. `my()` always affects private variables, also called lexical variables or (improperly) static(ly scoped) variables.

For instance:

        sub visible {
            print "var has value $var\n";
        }

        sub dynamic {
            local $var = 'local';   # new temporary value for the still-global
            visible();              #   variable called $var
        }

        sub lexical {
            my $var = 'private';    # new private variable, $var
            visible();              # (invisible outside of sub scope)
        }

        $var = 'global';

        visible();                  # prints global
        dynamic();                  # prints local
        lexical();                  # prints global

Notice how at no point does the value ``private'' get printed. That's because $var only has that value within the block of the `lexical()` function, and it is hidden from called subroutine.

In summary, `local()` doesn't make what you think of as private, local variables. It gives a global variable a temporary value. `my()` is what you're looking for if you want private variables.

See Private Variables via my() in the perlsub manpage and Temporary Values via local() in the perlsub manpage for excruciating details.

## How can I access a dynamic variable while a similarly named lexical is in scope?

If you know your package, you can just mention it explicitly, as in $Some_Pack::var. Note that the notation $::var is not the dynamic $var in the current package, but rather the one in the ``main'' package, as though you had written $main::var.

            use vars '$var';
            local $var = "global";
            my    $var = "lexical";

            print "lexical is $var\n";
            print "global  is $main::var\n";

Alternatively you can use the compiler directive `our()` to bring a dynamic variable into the current lexical scope.

            require 5.006; # our() did not exist before 5.6
            use vars '$var';

            local $var = "global";
            my $var    = "lexical";

            print "lexical is $var\n";

            {
              our $var;
              print "global  is $var\n";
            }

## What's the difference between deep and shallow binding?

In deep binding, lexical variables mentioned in anonymous subroutines are the same ones that were in scope when the subroutine was created. In shallow binding, they are whichever variables with the same names happen to be in scope when the subroutine is called. Perl always uses deep binding of lexical variables (i.e., those created with my()). However, dynamic variables (aka global, local, or package variables) are effectively shallowly bound. Consider this just one more reason not to use them. See the answer to What's a closure?.

## Why doesn't ``my($foo) = <FILE>;'' work right?

`my()` and `local()` give list context to the right hand side of `=`. The <FH> read operation, like so many of Perl's functions and operators, can tell which context it was called in and behaves appropriately. In general, the `scalar()` function can help. This function does nothing to the data itself (contrary to popular myth) but rather tells its argument to behave in whatever its scalar fashion is. If that function doesn't have a defined scalar behavior, this of course doesn't help you (such as with sort()).

To enforce scalar context in this particular case, however, you need merely omit the parentheses:

        local($foo) = <FILE>;           # WRONG
        local($foo) = scalar(<FILE>);   # ok
        local $foo  = <FILE>;           # right

You should probably be using lexical variables anyway, although the issue is the same here:

        my($foo) = <FILE>;  # WRONG
        my $foo  = <FILE>;  # right

## How do I redefine a builtin function, operator, or method?

Why do you want to do that? :-)

If you want to override a predefined function, such as open(), then you'll have to import the new definition from a different module. See Overriding Built-in Functions in the perlsub manpage. There's also an example in Class::Template in the perltoot manpage.

If you want to overload a Perl operator, such as `+` or `**`, then you'll want to use the `use overload` pragma, documented in the overload manpage.

If you're talking about obscuring method calls in parent classes, see Overridden Methods in the perltoot manpage.

## What's the difference between calling a function as &foo and foo()?

When you call a function as `&foo`, you allow that function access to your current @_ values, and you bypass prototypes. The function doesn't get an empty @_--it gets yours! While not strictly speaking a bug (it's documented that way in the perlsub manpage), it would be hard to consider this a feature in most cases.

When you call your function as `&foo()`, then you do get a new @_, but prototyping is still circumvented.

Normally, you want to call a function using `foo()`. You may only omit the parentheses if the function is already known to the compiler because it already saw the definition (`use` but not `require`), or via a forward reference or `use subs` declaration. Even in this case, you get a clean @_ without any of the old values leaking through where they don't belong.

## How do I create a switch or case statement?

This is explained in more depth in the the perlsyn manpage. Briefly, there's no official case statement, because of the variety of tests possible in Perl (numeric comparison, string comparison, glob comparison, regex matching, overloaded comparisons, ...). Larry couldn't decide how best to do this, so he left it out, even though it's been on the wish list since perl1.

Starting from Perl 5.8 to get switch and case one can use the Switch extension and say:

            use Switch;

after which one has switch and case. It is not as fast as it could be because it's not really part of the language (it's done using source filters) but it is available, and it's very flexible.

But if one wants to use pure Perl, the general answer is to write a construct like this:

        for ($variable_to_test) {
            if    (/pat1/)  { }     # do something
            elsif (/pat2/)  { }     # do something else
            elsif (/pat3/)  { }     # do something else
            else            { }     # default
        }

Here's a simple example of a switch based on pattern matching, this time lined up in a way to make it look more like a switch statement. We'll do a multiway conditional based on the type of reference stored in $whatchamacallit:

        SWITCH: for (ref $whatchamacallit) {

            /^$/            && die "not a reference";

            /SCALAR/        && do {
                                    print_scalar($$ref);
                                    last SWITCH;
                            };

            /ARRAY/         && do {
                                    print_array(@$ref);
                                    last SWITCH;
                            };

            /HASH/          && do {
                                    print_hash(%$ref);
                                    last SWITCH;
                            };

            /CODE/          && do {
                                    warn "can't print function ref";
                                    last SWITCH;
                            };

            # DEFAULT

            warn "User defined type skipped";

        }

See `perlsyn/"Basic BLOCKs and Switch Statements"` for many other examples in this style.

Sometimes you should change the positions of the constant and the variable. For example, let's say you wanted to test which of many answers you were given, but in a case-insensitive way that also allows abbreviations. You can use the following technique if the strings all start with different characters or if you want to arrange the matches so that one takes precedence over another, as `"SEND"` has precedence over `"STOP"` here:

        chomp($answer = <>);
        if    ("SEND"  =~ /^\Q$answer/i) { print "Action is send\n"  }
        elsif ("STOP"  =~ /^\Q$answer/i) { print "Action is stop\n"  }
        elsif ("ABORT" =~ /^\Q$answer/i) { print "Action is abort\n" }
        elsif ("LIST"  =~ /^\Q$answer/i) { print "Action is list\n"  }
        elsif ("EDIT"  =~ /^\Q$answer/i) { print "Action is edit\n"  }

A totally different approach is to create a hash of function references.

        my %commands = (
            "happy" => \&joy,
            "sad",  => \&sullen,
            "done"  => sub { die "See ya!" },
            "mad"   => \&angry,
        );

        print "How are you? ";
        chomp($string = <STDIN>);
        if ($commands{$string}) {
            $commands{$string}->();
        } else {
            print "No such command: $string\n";
        }

## How can I catch accesses to undefined variables, functions, or methods?

The AUTOLOAD method, discussed in Autoloading in the perlsub manpage and AUTOLOAD: Proxy Methods in the perltoot manpage, lets you capture calls to undefined functions and methods.

When it comes to undefined variables that would trigger a warning under `use warnings`, you can promote the warning to an error.

            use warnings FATAL => qw(uninitialized);

## Why can't a method included in this same file be found?

Some possible reasons: your inheritance is getting confused, you've misspelled the method name, or the object is of the wrong type. Check out the perltoot manpage for details about any of the above cases. You may also use `print ref($object)` to find out the class `$object` was blessed into.

Another possible reason for problems is because you've used the indirect object syntax (eg, `find Guru "Samy"`) on a class name before Perl has seen that such a package exists. It's wisest to make sure your packages are all defined before you start using them, which will be taken care of if you use the `use` statement instead of `require`. If not, make sure to use arrow notation (eg., `Guru->find("Samy")`) instead. Object notation is explained in the perlobj manpage.

Make sure to read about creating modules in the perlmod manpage and the perils of indirect objects in Method Invocation in the perlobj manpage.

## How can I find out my current package?

If you're just a random program, you can do this to find out what the currently compiled package is:

        my $packname = __PACKAGE__;

But, if you're a method and you want to print an error message that includes the kind of object you were called on (which is not necessarily the same as the one in which you were compiled):

        sub amethod {
            my $self  = shift;
            my $class = ref($self) || $self;
            warn "called me from a $class object";
        }

## How can I comment out a large block of perl code?

You can use embedded POD to discard it. Enclose the blocks you want to comment out in POD markers, for example `=for nobody` and `=cut` (which marks ends of POD blocks).

        # program is here

        =for nobody

        all of this stuff

        here will be ignored
        by everyone

        =cut

        # program continues

The pod directives cannot go just anywhere. You must put a pod directive where the parser is expecting a new statement, not just in the middle of an expression or some other arbitrary grammar production.

See the perlpod manpage for more details.

## How do I clear a package?

Use this code, provided by Mark-Jason Dominus:

        sub scrub_package {
            no strict 'refs';
            my $pack = shift;
            die "Shouldn't delete main package"
                if $pack eq "" || $pack eq "main";
            my $stash = *{$pack . '::'}{HASH};
            my $name;
            foreach $name (keys %$stash) {
                my $fullname = $pack . '::' . $name;
                # Get rid of everything with that name.
                undef $$fullname;
                undef @$fullname;
                undef %$fullname;
                undef &$fullname;
                undef *$fullname;
            }
        }

Or, if you're using a recent release of Perl, you can just use the Symbol::delete_package() function instead.

## How can I use a variable as a variable name?

Beginners often think they want to have a variable contain the name of a variable.

        $fred    = 23;
        $varname = "fred";
        ++$$varname;         # $fred now 24

This works sometimes, but it is a very bad idea for two reasons.

The first reason is that this technique only works on global variables. That means that if $fred is a lexical variable created with `my()` in the above example, the code wouldn't work at all: you'd accidentally access the global and skip right over the private lexical altogether. Global variables are bad because they can easily collide accidentally and in general make for non-scalable and confusing code.

Symbolic references are forbidden under the `use strict` pragma. They are not true references and consequently are not reference counted or garbage collected.

The other reason why using a variable to hold the name of another variable is a bad idea is that the question often stems from a lack of understanding of Perl data structures, particularly hashes. By using symbolic references, you are just using the package's symbol-table hash (like `%main::`) instead of a user-defined hash. The solution is to use your own hash or a real reference instead.

        $USER_VARS{"fred"} = 23;
        $varname = "fred";
        $USER_VARS{$varname}++;  # not $$varname++

There we're using the %USER_VARS hash instead of symbolic references. Sometimes this comes up in reading strings from the user with variable references and wanting to expand them to the values of your perl program's variables. This is also a bad idea because it conflates the program-addressable namespace and the user-addressable one. Instead of reading a string and expanding it to the actual contents of your program's own variables:

        $str = 'this has a $fred and $barney in it';
        $str =~ s/(\$\w+)/$1/eeg;             # need double eval

it would be better to keep a hash around like %USER_VARS and have variable references actually refer to entries in that hash:

        $str =~ s/\$(\w+)/$USER_VARS{$1}/g;   # no /e here at all

That's faster, cleaner, and safer than the previous approach. Of course, you don't need to use a dollar sign. You could use your own scheme to make it less confusing, like bracketed percent symbols, etc.

        $str = 'this has a %fred% and %barney% in it';
        $str =~ s/%(\w+)%/$USER_VARS{$1}/g;   # no /e here at all

Another reason that folks sometimes think they want a variable to contain the name of a variable is because they don't know how to build proper data structures using hashes. For example, let's say they wanted two hashes in their program: %fred and %barney, and that they wanted to use another scalar variable to refer to those by name.

        $name = "fred";
        $$name{WIFE} = "wilma";     # set %fred

        $name = "barney";
        $$name{WIFE} = "betty";     # set %barney

This is still a symbolic reference, and is still saddled with the problems enumerated above. It would be far better to write:

        $folks{"fred"}{WIFE}   = "wilma";
        $folks{"barney"}{WIFE} = "betty";

And just use a multilevel hash to start with.

The only times that you absolutely must use symbolic references are when you really must refer to the symbol table. This may be because it's something that can't take a real reference to, such as a format name. Doing so may also be important for method calls, since these always go through the symbol table for resolution.

In those cases, you would turn off `strict 'refs'` temporarily so you can play around with the symbol table. For example:

        @colors = qw(red blue green yellow orange purple violet);
        for my $name (@colors) {
            no strict 'refs';  # renege for the block
            *$name = sub { "<FONT COLOR='$name'>@_</FONT>" };
        }

All those functions (red(), blue(), green(), etc.) appear to be separate, but the real code in the closure actually was compiled only once.

So, sometimes you might want to use symbolic references to directly manipulate the symbol table. This doesn't matter for formats, handles, and subroutines, because they are always global--you can't use `my()` on them. For scalars, arrays, and hashes, though--and usually for subroutines-- you probably only want to use hard references.

## What does ``bad interpreter'' mean?

The ``bad interpreter'' message comes from the shell, not perl. The actual message may vary depending on your platform, shell, and locale settings.

If you see ``bad interpreter - no such file or directory'', the first line in your perl script (the ``shebang'' line) does not contain the right path to perl (or any other program capable of running scripts). Sometimes this happens when you move the script from one machine to another and each machine has a different path to perl---/usr/bin/perl versus /usr/local/bin/perl for instance.

If you see ``bad interpreter: Permission denied'', you need to make your script executable.

In either case, you should still be able to run the scripts with perl explicitly:

            % perl script.pl

If you get a message like ``perl: command not found'', perl is not in your PATH, which might also mean that the location of perl is not where you expect it so you need to adjust your shebang line.

# AUTHOR AND COPYRIGHT

Copyright (c) 1997-2002 Tom Christiansen and Nathan Torkington. All rights reserved.

This documentation is free; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the same terms as Perl itself.

Irrespective of its distribution, all code examples in this file are hereby placed into the public domain. You are permitted and encouraged to use this code in your own programs for fun or for profit as you see fit. A simple comment in the code giving credit would be courteous but is not required.

perlfaq7 - General Perl Language Issues